Tuesday, 26 August 2025

Stupor Mundi


Stupor Mundi was the name given to the Holy Roman Emperor Frederick II, and it meant the wonder of the world. He was an industrious and forward-thinking leader. In the game Stupor Mundi you play vassals of the great leader. You build your own castles and develop your own kingdoms, while at the same time you can influence Frederick’s progress in building his castle.


This is your player board. You have a site for building your own castle. There are two types of construction material - grain and stone. You will be producing, buying and selling them throughout the game. Completing different structures give you different benefits. Building walls increases your storage capacity. Completed wall sections, i.e. wall plus the towers at both ends, generate income every round. Towers give you space for recruiting allies, and allies give you points every round based on specific criteria. Building sections of the keep gives you strong powers, one of  which is being able to perform 6 instead of 5 actions every round. 

The action system is interesting. This part of the game is a deck-building game. You have a deck of 10 cards, and every round you will draw a subset. On your turn you play a card to perform an action. That card must be inserted into one of the slots below your player board. If a card is played face-up, you perform the action on the card. If the card is played face-down, you perform an action on your board. If you look at the screenshot above, the card back (yellow) shows two soldiers holding spears. The icons these spears point at are the options you have. I find this clever and also funny. I imagine the two soldiers muttering, yes sir you can do this, and this. During the game it is possible to buy action cards. This is the deck-building aspect. Cards you buy will be stronger than your initial cards. 


This is the main board, showing five different port cities. On your turn you always have the option to sail or to stay. Ports offer different rates for buying and selling goods, different allies, and different action cards. If you want to sail far, you need to pay extra. Trading is important. Selling high and buying low is an effective way to get the resources you need for construction.


This is Frederick's castle. This somewhat simulates a player board. How much money, stone and grain Frederick has can be affected by the players. The construction progress too can be influenced. One funny thing about this game is you can undo his construction. Thankfully your own construction progress does not get undone. Players want to break down Frederick's walls and towers mainly because of the allies. Some allies score more points if the player has more of a certain structure type than Frederick. So if you have that ally, you want to tear down the boss' structures. But if another player has that ally, you want to help the boss build quickly to prevent your opponent from scoring more points. Sad to say this, but the boss becomes a tool and a victim in office politics. 

Frederick's status changes through edicts, those tiles on the right. Certain things that players do allow them to issue edicts, and there are always three to choose from. Edicts specify which aspects of Frederick's castle you can change, and usually you get to choose whether to increase or decrease. 


This is a board for specialists. Every player has some, and Frederick has one too. Some actions allow you to advance a specialist. Depending on where they are, you gain certain privileges, for example scoring points whenever you recruit an ally. When your specialist moves to the next space, you lose the privilege on the previous space. However the spaces on the right are usually more powerful. Frederick doesn't actually make use of his specialist. It is there just to see whether the players have a stronger specialist than him. Again, this is related to ally scoring. 

I find Stupor Mundi fascinating. I would classify this as a development game. Generally you are producing resources, and also buying and selling them, so that you can afford to build structures. Completing your castle is your main storyline. What I find interesting is the many ways you can enhance your abilities. Different structures you build will give you different strengths. Which ones do you go for first? Do you work towards unlocking your 6th action as soon as possible? Do you try to get some allies quickly and milk them for points as early as possible? Do you invest in better action cards early? I like how the many elements are closely integrated. If you want to buy and sell efficiently, you must build walls in order to increase storage. Choosing where to slot an action card is not always easy to decide. Using a slot means reducing your action options for the rest of the round. 

The specialist advancements is fun to manage. It's a timing puzzle. If you think you will be doing a certain action a lot in the next few rounds, it will be best to have your specialist on a space that gives you a discount or a bonus when you perform that action. 

You don't directly attack your opponent, but you will be competing for allies and action cards on the main board. Since you can influence Frederick's status, you want to do it in such a way that you deny your opponents from scoring the full points from their allies. Manipulating Frederick's status is not something you get to do often. If you can deny your opponents, it will usually be a pain for them to change the situation back to one that's favourable to them. You need to consider carefully which allies to take. You don't want to spend a whole lot of effort only to find that your ally is quickly rendered useless. 

I was nasty and did my best to disable Han's allies. See the red crosses above three of his four allies. 

By late game we both had all our towers and walls built, but we did not complete our main keeps.


Our game ended when we ran out of edicts. We fooled around with our boss' castle so much that it was in shambles and he had no money left, just a large stockpile of unused stones. So much for being the wonder of the world when he had such corrupt and scheming vassals. 

Stupor Mundi is largely in the mould of the heavy Eurogame. You score points here and there. You collect resources and spend them to build something. However I find the package as a whole brilliant. It keeps you agonising about putting together enough resources for the next construction. There are many ways you can improve your capabilities, and you have to prioritise which ones to go for. There are tactical opportunities to pursue, but which ones do you want to commit your time and energy to? There is a constant struggle between wanting to do things which improve your abilities, and wanting to do things which get you points.  

Monday, 25 August 2025

Monster Taiwan (妖怪台湾)


Sometimes when I buy games, in particular those from lesser known brands, I try to guess how experienced the game designer and publisher are based on the game design, the rulebook, and the overall production of the game. Yes, sorry, I’m judging people. With big brands, you can always expect a high level of polish, because these guys are experienced. With lesser known or unknown brands, it’s like doing a lucky draw. Sometimes you find interesting and bold ideas. Sometimes you question the design decisions. Sometimes you see tell-tale signs of inexperience. Sometimes it is the thrill of this kind of lucky draw that makes me buy a game.

Monster Taiwan is from Taiwanese publisher TWOPLUS and they have been around since 2008. This is a game with much local flavour. It introduces many monsters and ghosts from Taiwanese folklore. The monsters are not necessarily malevolent. Sometimes people use them to do evil, but sometimes people use them for good. As human society advances, we believe less and less in monsters and ghosts. When humankind gradually interacts less with the monsters, they become forgotten. This is the key message in the game. I feel the monsters symbolise part of traditional culture that is becoming lost. 

Some of the monsters in the game

This is a dice drafting game played over four rounds (seasons). Every season there are five monsters accessible to players. If you activate them, you get to use their powers. You can draft dice to place directly on monsters. Monsters have limited slots for dice and the slots require dice of specific values. You can also draft dice to your own player board, which is your village. At the end of every round, there is a strength comparison and scoring for all three terrain types in villages. Another thing you can do is spend dice from your village to activate a monster. This weakens your village, and also it’s a two step process compared to directly placing a die from the dice pool to a monster, but there is one important benefit you gain when you do this. You get to claim one of only two tokens associated with that monster. Tokens will be worth points at the end of the game if the monsters are not forgotten. 

The dice tray has slots for five monsters around it.

The player board

If die colour matches terrain, score 1 point.

This monster reduces green die values

This monster steals a victory point

At the end of every round, two monsters least activated will be forgotten, i.e. discarded and replaced. Their tokens are worth nothing now. Monsters which survive all four rounds are worth many points. Those which only appear in the final round are worth much less. 

The markers for the four seasons indicate how long a monster has been in play.

Monster tokens


Another way you score points is by fulfilling missions. They require that you have dice in your village of specific values on specific terrain. Some missions instead of giving points grant an additional ability. For example the rightmost mission above gives you a virtual brown or blue die of value 1. You can use this virtual die to fulfil future missions. 


When contemplating whether to buy the game, it was partly the dice which made me decide to buy. I thought in the worst case if I disliked the game, I could try to design my own game using these pretty dice. 

I did a two player game with Chen Rui. I find the game a little problematic with just two. This is because every monster has two tokens. If we both activate the same valuable monster, then we neutralise each other, and this aspect of the competition becomes pretty boring. You always make sure you invest in any monster which looks like it will survive. Maybe with two players one token needs to be removed. Then the players will have meaningful competition trying to disqualify monsters the other player has invested in. 

Overall, I didn't find the game interesting. You try to score some points by fulfilling missions. You try to populate the different terrains in your village more than your opponents. You want to activate monsters to attack your opponents, to help yourself, or to invest in them and keep them in play. This is a perfect information game, since everything is open information. 

Sunday, 24 August 2025

Planet Unknown


Planet Unknown is a game about exploring a newly discovered planet to see whether it is going to be habitable by humans. This is a polyomino game in which you try to fill your own player board. Polyomino tiles are laid out on a Lazy Susan which is rotated every turn. You always have two pieces before you, and you must pick one to place on your planet. The game ends when one player is unable to place either of his options. 




A tile you pick always has two colours. These colours let you advance on the corresponding technology tracks. There are five such technology tracks. When you reach certain positions, you get some benefit. Benefits include victory points, special abilities, free advancements on another track, and so on. If there are specific tracks you want to focus on, you will tend to choose tiles with those colours. 


The different tile colours have different characteristics. Red tiles often let you move your rovers. Rovers are used to get rid of meteors. Some tiles come with meteors, and if they are not removed, they make their spaces unusable. Removed meteors give points. Blue tiles are quick in giving you points, but only if they are placed on water terrain. When advancing on the green track, one benefit you can gain is single square tiles which help tremendously in filling your planet without leaving gaps. 


At the end of the game, complete rows and columns score points. Meteors and barrels collected score points. Advancements on technology tracks as well. Although the game is mostly solitaire, there is one aspect where you will compete with other players. There are several bonus scoring criteria. If you fulfil the conditions better than your opponents, you will score bonus points. This influences how you plan in filling up your planet. You will probably choose to fulfil some and concede on others. Decisions, decisions, decisions.

Those icons along the top refer to the bonus scoring criteria.

One-time benefits when you reach certain points on the black track.

I really enjoyed the experience of playing Planet ‎Unknown. I find it soothing and satisfying. You can plan a few turns ahead which tiles to take and how to fill your board leaving as few gaps as possible. What tiles and colours become available to you is subject to luck. You don’t always get what you want. However, you can still make the most out of what you are dealt. It is mostly a solitaire game, and usually I prefer games with more player interaction. Yet I find this game a joy to play. It is a rewarding experience to see all the pieces fall in place.

Saturday, 23 August 2025

boardgaming in photos: Taiwan trip, Elfenland, Pax Renaissance


June this year I visited Taiwan with my family. Taiwan was where I got into the boardgaming hobby. I first learned about the world of German games there. I became a fan. That was in 2003. I worked and lived in Taipei from 2003 to 2004. After falling in love with boardgames, I also introduced them to my colleagues. We used to play over lunch time, hurriedly finishing our meals. I remember once when a public holiday was declared due to a typhoon, we ended up meeting up to play, because that typhoon turned out to be less severe than expected. 

Well before the trip I arranged to meet up with my Taiwanese friends. Unfortunately many of them were not in town when I was there. Only Crystal and Jessy were able to meet up. The last time I visited Taipei was 10 years ago, in 2015. I hope the next time won't take another 10 years. 

We played Ali Baba and the Forty Thieves


In 2004 when I visited a night market it Taipei, I bought some cheap plastic chips similar to these above. I sometimes use these when the boardgame I play uses paper money. For example Power Grid. I have been using my cheap poker chips for more than 20 years. In recent years, they play a new role. I use them when designing and playtesting games. By now, a few of the poker chips have gone missing, but most of them are still there and they still work fine. I don't really need to buy more. I bought these two sets above mostly out of nostalgia. These two use a different colour scheme from my old sets. 


During the trip when I have the opportunity to visit bookstores I check out their boardgame sections. I ended up buying these games above. The one at the lower right was bought at a museum in Kaohsiung. I did not research boardgame stores in Taiwan and I did not plan to visit them. I considered visiting Witch House, which was where I learned about German games more than 20 years ago. I used to play games there regularly. However I found out that now they only have boardgame time on weekends. The only day I could visit them was a Wednesday. So eventually I decided not to go. 

Of the four games above, I have played them all by now. They are all in my queue to write about. In the past ten years I have not been buying many games. At least not by gamer standards. However in the most recent few years, I have started buying more again, and the reasons I buy games have changed. I no longer buy just because I think it's a game I'll like. Sometimes I buy a game because I want to see how other people design and produce a game. I buy because I too am a designer and publisher now, and I want to learn. The game is reference material. This time in Taiwan, I bought games not just as games but also as souvenirs. In different places, and with different people, who have different personal experiences and histories, you get different kinds of games. The games are a snapshot and a reflection of a time and place, a culture, a society. I find that uniqueness fascinating. 


Elfenland is an old game by Alan Moon of Ticket to Ride fame. It was the 1998 Spiel des Jahres winner, 6 years before Ticket to Ride won it. I checked my records, and the previous time I played this was 2007. In 1998, there weren't any heavy Eurogames like we do now. When playing games from the late 90's, I find them clean and simple, yet strategic and smart. They feel like a breath of fresh air. You don't get overburdened by too many rules and subsystems. I wonder whether I'm just being the nostalgic old fart. 


Elfenland is played over four rounds. Your goal is to visit as many cities as possible. You place transportation tokens on paths. This opens them up for us, and at the same time also determines the modes of transportation you must use. To travel, you spend cards, which are the various modes of transportation - dragons, clouds, rafts, unicorns, boars and so on. 


I have played a physical copy of Pax Renaissance before. This is a game about the Age of Renaissance in Europe. The board is divided into 10 major kingdoms. You buy cards which allow you to do all sorts of things, like taking control of kingdoms, changing them to republics (or back), creating armies, initiating wars, influencing religions and so on. 


There are four ways to win. As you manipulate the political scene in Europe, you must think carefully which one to go for. While you work towards that, you need to remember to stop your opponents from achieving their goals too. Achieving a winning condition doesn't mean you immediately win. The victory condition needs to be enabled first, by buying a comet card. Comet cards only start appearing in the second half of the game. 


I was pretty extreme in this particular game. All the cards I bought were for the western half of Europe. I had no influence in eastern Europe, but when I had so many cards for the western half, I could do many many things every turn. When you take an action to activate cards, you must choose either east or west. 

At this point 5 of the kingdom cards had been claimed.

This winning condition is globalisation. 

Friday, 22 August 2025

Kinapa


Kinapa is an unusual game. I am still not sure whether it's a game I don't like, or a game I don't understand. Many others have played it and found it unique (in a good way). Their comments make me doubt myself. Some who don't like it say it's just like Go Fish, but I disagree about the similarity. In Go Fish you may not lie about whether you have a card. In Kinapa you may. 


Kinapa is a card game for 2 to 8 players. I believe it is designed primarily for 4 to 8, because to play with 2 or 3 you need to use variant rules. The number of hand cards used is always 4 times the number of players, because players start with a hand of four cards. Your goal is to play all four of your cards. All numbers in the game appear twice. What you want to do is to collect both cards of the same value, and then play them to a base. In the photo above there are two cards numbered 13. So that's a pair. There is also a base which shows a fan, and it has the numbers 13 and 14. This means the base can accept a pair of 13's or a pair of 14's. The goal is pretty straightforward. 

The bases are shuffled and placed face-down at the centre of the table. There will be enough bases for all the pairs, just that at the beginning no one knows which bases allow which numbers. The active player (called the emperor) starts his turn by openly demanding a number. All other players must, on the count of three, respond to the demand at the same time. You either raise your hand to state that you don't have the number (you may lie), or you do nothing. There are several possible situations. If two or more players do nothing, then assuming that everyone is honest, the card the emperor wants is with one of these players who do nothing. The emperor picks one of them and randomly draws one of their cards, then give a different card in return. Now if the number of players who do nothing is 0 or 1, whoever has the card the emperor demands must surrender it. If the card comes from someone who has raised his hand, it means he has lied, and he is now caught lying. He will be penalised. Here is yet another situation. The emperor may already have a pair and still ask for that number. If everyone raises their hands, the emperor does not need to swap a card. He just needs to show his pair. 

After the demand step is completed, the second thing the emperor must do is to reveal an unoccupied base. If it matches a pair he has, he plays that pair to the base, and he reveals another base. If the emperor plays his second pair, he wins the game. If he is unable to play, the base is flipped back face-down. You need to try to remember what number it has. This is also a memory game. 

I find reading the rules rather challenging. The rules are hard to digest and remember. I'm not sure whether it's because of the game design or the way the rules are written. I feel the game can be simplified. When teaching the game, I had to look up the rules several times, because I realised I didn't know what to do when I encountered a certain situation. One thing I still don't quite get is this. Isn't it best to always not raise your hand? This way, everyone minimises helping the emperor. Also you won't be caught lying or be penalised for it. The game becomes just the emperor randomly picking someone to swap a card with. Why would you want to raise your hand? Is it because you already have a pair and don't want the emperor taking your card? 


One thing I find annoying is these sheep cards above. Whenever you become emperor, you must take a sheep card too. Anyone with a sheep card may not become emperor again, until everyone has a sheep card and they are then all returned to the centre. This is a mechanism to make sure everyone gets to be emperor once before anyone does it again a second time. Turn order is not clockwise. It is always the current emperor who decides who is next, except he cannot pick someone with a sheep card. Yet another exception is if someone has a fox card but not a sheep card, he must go next. 

The fox cards are the penalty for getting caught lying. This happens in a very specific situation - you have raised your hand, and that turn no one or just one person has his hand down, and you have the card the emperor wants, and you have been forced to surrender it. The penalty is for two turns you play with your hand open. The two fox cards are a countdown mechanism. 

I feel the game has many fiddly rules, making it complicated and hard to remember. I wonder whether they are necessary. Possibly I haven't fully grasped the fun in the game, so I can't appreciate why the rules are needed. I have only played one game, and I didn't even teach or play it correctly. I should play again, and play it correctly, before I draw any conclusion. 

Thursday, 21 August 2025

Mass Effect: The Board Game


Mass Effect is a popular console game. It is a third person role playing game set in a sci-fi world. The boardgame version was released in 2024. One of the designers is Eric Lang, the hugely popular game designer who has done many Fantasy Flight Games titles. The other designer is Calvin Wong, a fellow Malaysian. This is like the dream for us Malaysian game designers - having the opportunity to design a game with a world top-level game designer. 

Notice that the box cover has Calvin's Chinese name as well. The publisher took this very seriously. When they decided to put the Chinese name, they did not just use any random font. They contacted the console game localisation company in China and asked them for the official font in the Chinese edition of the game. I admire that they take these production details so seriously. 


I visited Calvin's booth at the Asian Board Games Festival in Penang, where he showcased Mass Effect. I did not sit down to play a game, but I asked him to give me an overview of how the game works. The design direction behind this game is to make something that is accessible to many people. The target audience is fans of the console game. The idea is to get them interested to try the board game version of the game. Many of them may not be boardgame players. Yet. 

The game is scenario based. When you sit down to play, you pick a scenario which has its own map and setup. Regardless of the number of players, there will always be four characters in play. If you have fewer than four players, some of you will play more than one character. Each scenario has its own winning and losing conditions. A scenario does not take too long, so that if you want to, you can play a series of two to three scenarios within one evening. There is a plot line structure which links together multiple scenarios. This creates the experience of playing a campaign. What happens in one scenario carries over to the next. You don't always play with the four fixed characters. There are more than four to choose from so you can try different combinations.


These are some of the characters you can play. Every character has their own character sheet. They have their own sets of abilities and also possible upgrades. 

You get to play these characters.


When a round begins, the start player rolls a whole bunch of dice. Thereafter everyone takes turns utilising three dice. The icons on the dice specify what kind of actions you can take. You take turns executing actions until the dice are used up. This is a cooperative game. You work together as a team to complete your mission.

Calvin Wong the game designer

Wednesday, 20 August 2025

Cat & Chocolate

 


Cat & Chocolate is a game from Japan first published in 2010. It is an award winner in Japan. This is a party game and it is of the type where you need to be a convincing speaker. This is partly a social deduction game. Players are divided into two teams. You know which team you belong to, but you have no idea who your teammates are. When the game ends, your team identities are revealed, and each team adds up their points to see who wins. What this means is throughout the game you want to do your best to score points, because that will help, regardless of which team you are on. 


Every round, one player will be the storyteller, and the others the judges. As the storyteller, you reveal one situation card from the deck, and you must play one, two or three item cards from your hand which can be used to resolve the situation. You have a hand of only three cards. Your job is to convince everyone that the item or items you play will help you get out that particular difficult situation. After you explain, everyone else votes and this determines whether you score one point. The game keeps going like this, until the game end card turns up. The game end card is inserted roughly in the middle of the deck before the game starts. 

The two factions, and some of the situations

The scenarios are all horror movie type situations. Everything happens in an old mysterious mansion. You have ghosts, monsters, zombies and so on. In most cases you are simply trying to survive an attack. 

When we played, the key question asked by Alex was how were we going to know who was on which team. There is nothing in the rules or game components which will help the players determine who is on which team. It is all up to the players themselves. You can tell others which team you are on. You can lie about it too. This part of the game has unreliable fun, and by that I mean whether it is fun depends a lot on the players. It can be fun, and it might also be boring. In my opinion the designer should do a bit more work to make the fun more reliable. 

If through discussion you manage to figure out who is friend and who is foe, the storytelling part of the game may become pointless. You should always vote yes for your teammates, and no for your opponents. I feel the intention of the designer is you should not figure out your teams during the game. It is only meant for the end-game revelation. 

The game is disappointing to me, especially since this was an award winner. However this was back in 2010, and at that time there probably weren't that many modern games designed in Japan in the first place. Japanese game design certainly has come a long way since then. Cat & Chocolate is that type of party game which depends on the creativity and expressiveness of the players. The kind with performances and judges. Not really my cup of tea. Also the design feels a little dated, now that I have seen many better Japanese games.